2 Cultural Ecology Theory
Articles Blog

2 Cultural Ecology Theory

[Music] you we had just discussed the different stages of societies beginning from the for aging the petrel societies industrial and agriculture and password industrial society and in these stages of societies we happen to business as the members of the society and increases it becomes it move on from symbol to a more complex form of in relationship so in essence we can presume that there is a an increase in terms of the division of labor which is more based on a specialized and skills of the individuals as we can see here member starts ooh and gets more in a different specialized role now perhaps this specialization is more with it and more clear in the industrial societies because this division of labor is based more or less on that level of expertise with an individual health now this division of labor perhaps has been the strongly discussed by the kind which of course we will be covering in this course but Durkheim tries to divide the differences between mechanical and organic solidarity and wearing he says in most of the simple and traditional societies the relationships shared among the members were more or less being mechanic and rather in the industrial and post-industrial society kind of solidarity with a group usually maintained is more less organic in nature now as a result of this this achieved from more of a movement from a military to an industrial society and now what happens in a military form of society more or less it is based on a compulsion or and a compulsory kind of cooperation of its members you know how the military functions right now depending on that this form of relationship usually is maintained by a compulsive kind of corporation which is expected from the members of the group and secondly the industrial society is also correct characterized by the voluntary cooperation of its members there is a differences between the military and the industrial because in the industrial it is small s based on voluntary wear in the military it is small s based on the compulsory cooperation which is expected from the members of the society and thirdly when society in essence with the states of an ethical state common resources in essence may be part of the human character in in essence they have reached a space of perfection now in this if you look at this the structural parts of how these society functions for example let’s take an example of families how they functioned they functions more or less in a independent Pender they work in a more more independent and therefore this social structure in a sense work together in order to preserve or maintain the society therefore the social fabric of the society is being stabilized based on this function now moving on as we had discussed the successive stages of society will partly try to look into how the production the modes of productions operate now for instance humans usually a base are usually guided by the the Signet and this basic needs in essence is central to a ways of life or maybe a social life and partly this the thickness or guiding principle is true in almost every forms of society be it the contemporary of modern field or maybe be the prehistoric period now in Samuel Dada these sort of basic needs has fins something which society has been after now what is this quest to meet this basic needs because normally these are based on the primary goals and which is being central to the attempts of human life and with of course more and more this basic needs shift and evolve so is the society which in essence move on from simple to from compound and more of complex kind of society now usually when this the cygnets are met this often create to the quest or yearning for further needs which means it sieves and it moves on because there’s no limit to it therefore humans by nature in essence is greedy and then we tend to yarn for more and more and in this process human struggled against it to satisfy if not gratified once needs now therefore we tend to involve in certain kind of exploitation and abuse of nature which is being part of the ballgame in our social rule or some in social structure which is part of inherent in the successive states of society and which I feel that to me this might perhaps be one of the reason why we have witness or encounter these ecological crisis and partly which perhaps might be pushed forward by the industrialization process and also because of the catalyst mode of production because we all know interpret this mode of production Goods and goods are produces and you tend to find Avenue to sell of those Goods now that’s how with that kind of intention and with this guide by this kind of economic mode of production the resources which perhaps has been there to sustain the basic needs of humans has been to some extent being more exploited in a wider and then in a fast-paced manner now as we had discussed in the press slides we in a sense tries to disk into how this ecology and what ecology is trying to engage and look upon because ecology no doubt sv by now I assume that you all know what ecology is it is the interactions or interrelationship which are being shared by the living beings or maybe the biotech or a non biotic in the environment and cultural ecologists in essence is engaged in trying to record part of the traditional knowledge that is valued to the wider world now cultural ecology innocence is generally included within the disciplines of anthropology and that is anthropology is a discipline which studies human beings or the human society now what the Anthropology the discipline of anthropology look at let me just give a brief introduction to what anthropology is and then what the discipline of anthropology looked at the study of anthropology includes the study of human biology language prehistory religions social structure economic evolutions and anything else that applies to people now you can actually break up all this because perhaps if you talk about culture can talk about the material culture non material culture and within religion belief ritual ceremonies now these are some of the branches or so to say the wider topics which are being usually covered within the study of anthropology and usually people who are engaged in studying anthropology or maybe who are in entropolis and guess in concentrating their work mostly on the small scale or simple societies or cultures and tend to have more of a personal contact with the people of those cultures by saying a personal contact we want to say they are usually been guided by the research methods such as ethnography now in ethnographic study what people do is usually they conduct a research or fieldwork in societies which are in a sense alien to them now there are some anthropologists who have like Malinowski Eva events Pritchard now they in essence engage in an ethnographic study in a more longer period which is also known as longitudinal study now they tend to take into account almost every nitty-gritty part of their culture and through this engagement they are able to interpret the hidden meanings which usually and outsiders can’t make sense of it now this perhaps is one of the advantage of being an anthropologist and the kind of tools and techniques which are being used in the study of any society or for that matter because it begins with trying to look at small scale if not simple societies now traditionally what anthropologists looked at is study the set of basic beliefs which usually is in the setting which is outside the domain of one’s culture now since an anthropologist is trying to look at or study a culture of a different society usually he or she and counter these ethnocentric feelings that is people normally and get in believing that culture that their own culture is superior than others and this kind of atmospheric or ethnocentrism is developed as a result of one own process of socialization now for instance you can have a look at the examples which I have given here now Americans usually tends to be non-american as being inferior with a less civilized and similarly you have that kind of feeling for instance Germans during the period of Hitler tends to see themselves as a pure race of the Aryan blood and they have that anti-semitic feelings against the views now these are Pauline personal reality which exist in humans Minds when they tend to compare with other groups of society now another conviction which an anthropologist and counter is that cultural relativism that is you tends to that the and cultural practices of others based on your cultural belief and practices now we have partly discussed the successive states of society and then and also how societies move on from more simple to complex one now we will try to shift into a different topic now which I feel is important and which I put it as a cultural ecological theory and in this we will try to look into the socio cultural materialism which is being posited by Merlin heaviest and how does he try to make sense of the sort of actions or how an individual or society and gets into some kind of accent and we will try to bring in the kind of social action which was discussed by Max Weber another German sociologist now what then is a cultural ecological theory a theory to begin with is nothing but a worldview you form some kind of an idea a concept and through that you are trying to look at things and you tend to innocence test it validate it and based on that findings you develop some kind of a cheery now usually in the these exercises it involves what or observation which of course is pretty much being used in social sciences and of course in the discipline of anthropology now in this exercises you tends to engage in looking at the origins maintenance and chills now what then is socio-cultural material isn’t now in this section we’ll try to address or examine the society from the lens of a socio-cultural methodology and socio-cultural matter vision is a theory of socio-cultural systems and as I said it is a variant which is being borrowed from Marvin Harris now let us try to assume because a theory in essence is also being hypothesized the worldview before you have the real context with the real world you tend to hypothesize certain elements which in essence guide you to interpret and make sense of what you observe now for instance what the first assumptions which in essence would guide us is how the various parts of societies are interrelated now it is quite interesting to see that how the parts of a body max a single body but then similarly the parts of a body in essence are interrelated and being representing the wholes or one single body now similarly we have different members defend groups who actually forms the larger single society and how is this interrelated and what are the kinds of functions which these members of the society are being interrelated now for instance over here I give an example of an institution such as family cannot be looked at in isolation therefore it is important to discuss or looked at the economic the political the social religious institution which within with a family functions therefore let’s presume that when one part of the society changes it also have an impact on other parts of the society and then definitely if one part changes the other part is also going to change now the intensity of their genes might be different in some it might be minimal and in some it might be much more higher now since the course is to deal with the ecology or environment therefore let us also assume that then one can base what we have what human societies are interrelated in essence our actions that is human actions does have an impact on the environment now as we begin humans are usually guided to fulfilled their quest for their basic needs now if we tries to see society as which are interrelated parts then obviously there will be some sort of an organizing principles that organizing principles will be sort of an integrating force which guides the members of the society now for instance the way how a society is organized to meet certain requirements the requirements can be infrastructure it can be superstructure now usually based on that the society tends to set that is the population tends to SEP or set the system now if we take the examples of the Hindu caste system the caste system which prevail earlier was more less based on the Werner’s system where in a particular group is engaged in a certain kind of occupation now over a period of time that sort of division becomes rigid and it becomes more of a structure if not part of the Hindu caste system now prior to what we have now or what is being encountered today this I mean during that pair of the word not system society innocence and gays in forming assistant in order to meet or to stabilize their I mean structure of society based on different functions right now I mean a certain group of people were engaged in else culture work certain in the work blacksmith here and then certain sections to be in the war front and some groups who are usually engaged in more of ritual ceremonies and religious practices now over a period of time that kind of profession becomes more of a scripted with the family or the Cos Cob tends to redefine that is how society is being stratified or being divided I would rather say in order to fulfill the kind of needs which we have now what is the environmental constraints with human society usually encounter now the first and foremost is the natural resources which is very important in order to sustain if not fulfilled the basic needs of humans now why is this Natural Resources so much important because the availability of Natural Resources might not be similar in every part of the world and so is the carrying capacity now if we take in samples of say a pollutant which of course is being created by humans through certain kinds of activities maybe the industry or maybe the kind of automobiles which we use now these are directly or indirectly responsible for the kind of environmental mess we create that is pollutant now how do we as a human tries to overcome an encounter this kind of problems because we tend to engage in finding an alternative way to modify these constraints because we can’t escape so we’ll have to find a different way of an alternative which I would say the adaptive mechanism of then random constraints now human societies in successive stages has come up with a different kind of adaptive mechanism in order to sustain if not adapt or exist with the environment now similarly present contemporary period is also witnessing like issues like climate change the ozone depletion now in a global form there has been different initiative taken by different reasons what could have perhaps be the possible solutions now when we discussed about what the infrastructure needs of humans now human usually encounters the interface of the socio-cultural systems and environment and it is through this interface the infrastructure that society tends to utilize or manipulate its environment the types of resources which actually is being needed now usually we in the previous lectures we have discussed how this resources is being controlled if not the distribution of resources is not equally distributed and this perhaps bring some kind of an environmental injustice to different communities now based on this idea one needs to engage in trying to find out if not the amount of consumptions which usually is required by a group needs to be in essence evaluated now the infrastructure which I discuss here consists of two parts that is the mode of production and reproduction so in a way we can say it is the consumer and the provider this interface is part and parcel of the ecosystem we’re in sometimes when the consumer is much more higher than the provider then a situation of imbalance also crop up now over here what is the mode of production and what is the reproduction the mode of production and reproduction in essence attempts to strike a balance because unless there is a balance between the two there will be definitely a collapse if not a destruction now for instance consumption of energy for instance usually if a particular community for example rely on fuel wood and footer in a particular geographical area now they have in essence been managing because this it also gives a space or a time for regeneration now if that resources is being exploited through some external forces maybe which is driven by the so called market economy now that might perhaps lead to a faster pace of destruction and there is an imbalance between the kind of dependence and mode of production and the reproduction now that becomes imbalance now what is mode of production then it in essence consists of are part-and-parcel actions of humans which tries to fulfill the requirements of subsistence or so to say the basic needs now in this we tend to engage in looking at the technological technology of the subsystems and the technological and at the same time the environmental relationship now why is this technology and environment interrelated because the more finer and the more advanced is the technology we used in essence it posed a threat to the environment is if not the kind of relationship which humans share with the environment changes now I’m just trying to partly highlight which more or less we have discussed already in the previous slides now how is this mode of production usually being classified or divided by mostly the anthropologist and sociologists and in this successive states of society we have a different form of socio-cultural system now for instance in hunting-and-gathering society the socio-cultural system might not be seen as the horticulture pest relief not agrarian and the industrial because if you compare the previous four with the last one that is the industrial society we tend to see that there is more of specialized and division of labor based on skills because the interrelationship or the parts of society becomes much more finer in the kind of jobs or profession which they are engaged now perhaps the system of bureaucratization or bureaucratic network which is guiding us in the present times perhaps we’ll be the best suited example how this part of the socio-cultural system or the working culture has changed over a period of time now it also consists of innocence the behavior which actually is being aimed at controlling the whole members of the society and functions if we pick the hunting and gathering Society what will they do or what will they and get into if they run out of food stock for example now it is up on this environmental infrastructure foundation that the remaining parts of the social systems are going to be decided upon now there is one of the reason why the environmental instructor infrastructure tends to hold a key positions in the interface of the human and environment now if you look at the social system you can break up by looking at some of these sub points like for instance demography the mating patterns fertility Nativity or maybe the modern forms of what contraception emotions and infanticide let’s assume that these are part of what the social system is and what are the kind of changes which are being witnessed now for instance what then is social structure it refers to the human groups and organizations and the social structure of human society can be perhaps divided into two is the primary and secondary groups now what is these primary groups it is more to do with the consisting of small group of members of the society maybe in the family or which usually regulate a face-to-face kind of contact in the exchange and consumptions more or less in the domestic settings and usually this relationship which is being shared in these primary groups are more intimate and as I say it’s more of a encounter when mutual encounter takes place physically now these are some of the groups which can be classified within the primary good that is the family the community and within this may be some voluntary groups and some religious group or may be your friends the kind of circle you have within your peer groups now in secondary organizations what do we have we have much more of a formulas formalized kind of relationship where in the group of groups in the members in the groups are being guided by certain rules and regulations right now that sort of relationship is formal in nature now for instance the institutions like the government military police corporations education media so and so forth can actually be put under these secondary organizations now what is the need why is the need for discussing this bureaucratization now this very Tom which is being to an extent discussed by Max Weber in his trying to posit about the kind of social changes or how the social functions changes in the industrial to post-industrial society and perhaps in his quest to elaborate and understand more of this rationalization of this accent he perhaps tends to see these bureaucratize Asian as one of the most based forms of this modern society now what do we have in this bureaucratization it the course of human evolution that is the successive states of in societies how division is being labor is being divided and how are the members of the society being divided as we had discussed there is an increasing division of labor that is from the more unspecialized to in a more specialized or from a more simple to a complex one and then this distribution or allocation of whatever is based on a psychological need and satisfaction and within this there emerges a class called elites who are this elite I will come back to the burrito patient in the later part but for the time being let’s look at what the Edit is it is based on the class sex race and then the status which usually exists throughout the structure of society now in almost every society there will be a class who are being in the upper layer of the society and which are considered to be much more garnering a lot of power and this power elites innocence might not be generalized and it might be different in across different societies this why is the privilege of the existence of elites innocence is necessary or what are the socio cultural system which in essence bring them into existence now usually because of the power relationship if not unequal distribution of wealth one section the society tends to be much more in advantageous positioned and then they tends to take control of the the socio-economic if not the political system and they happens to have enjoyed that particular status now in what I have discussed in the previous slides human needs infrastructure and also superstructure now what is the differences between the two now if you look at the superstructure which actually can also be further divided into two that is the cultural and mantle now the mantle is more of psychological and it in essence is also responded responsible for guiding human to engage in a certain kind of accent now what does this cultural superstructure but includes the recreation activities art sports empirical knowledge folklore and other aesthetics products and also maybe the music dance rituals so all these are part of the cultural superstructure which is embedded within a particular socio-cultural system of any society now the mental structures are more to do with an individual values emotions traditions and recreational now how is these two innocence interrelated because an individual innocence cannot act or function in isolation brother within the socio culture setting of a society therefore it is important to look at how this individual or that is the mental structure functions now Max Weber a German sociologist posits the idea that there are four basic motivators for human behavior because a human the whole body is also being influenced by certain kind of motivations that is our interest to pursue a specific task or gold now ideal types is an actual behavior which which is motivated by combination now the first type of this behavior which in essence motivate the human is the value oriented behavior what is this value oriented behavior then it is an accent which is being guided by a value now you tend to pursue a goal which you feel that it has more value the value can be more it can be based on for example if an individual attends a college because he values the life of the mind or maybe for knowledge 6 he wants to be an ax lighten or an educated person therefore he attends a college or pursue education so therefore that can be categorized as a behavior which is being motivated by a value so also doing the right thing out of religious or philosophical ideas of right and wrong that is we humans are guided by certain kind of concerns now based on the kind of religious upbringing or teachings which we normally encounter and experience in life we tend to you know like avoid certain elements such as doing or not engaging in an evil or doing some work to commit certain crimes now that can also be part of this value oriented behavior and the second is the rational accent which is in relation to a value now for instance carrying forward the examples which we have cited now attending a college because you value the life of the mind so in a way can be cited as again not example now the second thing is how is this the affective or emotional affective that is the emotional of human guide one’s behavior now normally we humans differ in terms of our reactions sometimes we are pretty much being reactive when we are in the condition of anger or when we are happy so we are not able to hide in essence our emotions so that in in-depth instances we become more reactive and perhaps that particular expression or action might not serve any purpose now for instance you attend a college for a good timer because your significant other attendance or maybe because you are attracted to someone or maybe you happens to be in love with someone and then that may be the primary reason why you simply go and attend colleges now those sort of behavior which are being guided by effect affective or emotions can be categorized under these examples now the necklace or the traditional behavior how is a behavior in essence in film influenced by one’s traditions now usually we have these customs and traditions if not norms and values which are pretty much embedded to every members by their group now and these customs and traditions usually guide us if not enabled human to engage in certain kinds of accent which which in essence can be may be considered as a privilege or maybe which is considered to be more of appreciated by the society now for instance maybe if you take the examples of the girl child education in the Indian context for example now educated parents normally encourage the respective of gender to engage in pursuing education now mostly in rural areas where terms are uneducated they might not get the same preference of treatment or mostly in the potato kind of society now we may not seem to be much more of as domestic helper and they might lose the chance of to attend or pursue any kind of education now whatever it is these are actions which are usually being guided by the rules and norms or if not the belief which the society which society has now this last one that is the way to rational how it does guide the behavior and action of man this is a rational action wherein individual is guided by a specific goal that is you tell to engage in pursuing or your action is guided by a rational goal now depending on that you tends to build certain ways to achieve that goal now for example your purpose of attending the college as we have discussed in the examples might not necessarily be based on your emotions or just because you are in love with someone or maybe you value education or maybe your family members have the traditions of getting education so apart from that keep keeping aside all those now your or purpose of attending a college or getting education is to get a job so you set a certain kind of gold and this particular gold lever has categorized it as the irrational accent or this is also known as vector S note now the another example which I gave here for example building a raft to cross a river studying to get a good grade now there will be different kind of actions or proposes which human might and get into so it might be short time it might be long term now depending on that we humans and get into pursuing or and get into that mean now what Weber noticed as a curious phenomenon in this read rational behavior is because there is an increasingly dominations of these sorts of behavior now why is this so because we humans are guided by a certain kind of interest now perhaps we can say this interest can be infrastructure determinism now what is this infrastructural determining determinism now the in essence the this is one of the major principles of socio-cultural materialism and in this the mode of production in essence and the reproduction is the mind the primary and secondary group structure which we have discussed the kind of relations which are being shared by members of the society which in essence also determined the cultural and mental superstructure now all this cannot be seen as in isolation rather it is in some way or the other interrelated now what is infrastructural determination determinism damnit now one of the rationale behind giving certain priorities in life is through these infrastructural practices the in essence society usually adapts to its environment because we tends to find a way how to add this and adapt to the environment and through which we engage in different kind of economic activities so to say our modes of production now for instance I if I give an example of a cultural community engaged in shifting cultivation if not zooming now from the perspective of the mainstream or dominant ideas those practices might be Tom as which is harmful or not really environmentally friendly now but from the perspective of those who practices this so to say shifting cultivation might be in essence the best way how they adapt to their environment and secondly it could be because the kind of geographical Tyrion which they inhabit might be conducive for that kind of agricultural practices so in a way I’m reciting an example of that because society adapts to its environment that is the infrastructure practices in essence is also being guided by the environment so in a way it is the environment which in essence influences the society and in return the society tends to engage in this infrastructural practices depending on the environment which they are into now it is through this infrastructure that society moves on that is the mode of production and it modifies in a sense the amount and types of resources required for life now what resources are we talking about here it talks about the amount of or the kind of basic needs which humans usually feel that they require in order for subsistence now since these infrastructural practices are essential for human existence this widespread structural and superstructure patterns must in a way be balanced that is it should be compatible with them now the intensification which is being business globally if you look at the because of the world population infrastructure industrial infrastructures are growing at an export exponential rate now obviously this will have an affair eating or oppression on the environment that is the resources and this growth or intensification has impact on other parts of the system as we have discussed in the beginning now if there is a change in one part of the society and obviously there will be a change in other parts so similarly your actions what you’re engaged in to definitely will have an imprint or a change on the overall system now coming back to what bureaucratization is if we try to link up with the idea of this intensification now in densification of infrastructure innocence causes the growth of secondary organizations at the expense of primary groups now what then is how is this being intensified this intensification process of the secondary group at the expense of smaller group is being realized because the intensification of infrastructure and bureaucratization of the structure caused the superstructure to rationalize that is their action whatever they do is considered to be rationalized now the increasing dominance of goal-oriented rational behavior at the expense of behavior guided by values traditions and emotions now this is the meaning of what rationalization is which means you are your action is guided by achieving the goal and in the process you compromise and you ignore the values traditions and emotions so by and large which means rationalization is nothing but it is the an action which is guided by a with a wasted interest to reach or achieve particular goal now in this when while discussing what the infrastructure is if infrastructure it becomes a primary importance the straw and superstructure in a way are not just a mere reflection of the infrastructural processes but are in interaction with this process and societies become very stable and the most likely outcome would be change in the system that is in resistance to other sectors of the society now this is something which would eventually be observed now in the case of these when rationalization is in to accent now we can partly look at the possible outcome that is to assess the outcome of this behavior accent the results either the extinctions or maybe the destruction or of the preserve and fundamental character of the whole system now one of the example is for instance income-tax women’s liberation community movement now all this kind of social engagement or accent in essence will bring a change to the whole that is it will bring an institutional chains or to reframe the existing norms and values with a society have been into it now for instance you can have a general observation or assessment how these socio-cultural chains release the energy from the environment is likely to be swiftly adopted now in essence there is this core relationship which exists among all these now infrastructure and environment relationship are also central in explaining the socio-cultural change now how is this infrastructure and environment interrelated in trying to look at or explain the socio-cultural change because we also need to recognize the importance of structures and super structures in trying to a sort of determined the speed and character of change it is rather tries allows us to understand the speed and pace of change how changes are going on is it in the fast pace pace or in a slow pace now it is through this infrastructure that humans are taking with it now if they move in a faster rate which means the technology is much more finer and then and that allows humans to move in a much more faster pace now what is in this what is the role of the edits what is the role of elites in this whole game now the changes which normally encounter in the socio-cultural setting their lives are able to impose sort of direct economic and political sanctions to get their way or maybe to serve their purpose because they have their own wasted interest and through this they usually engage in encouraging their or imposing their ideas and ideologies which are favorable to their positions now as a human we tend to be insecure or maybe to you know move up from the kind of position which we have now since they are in a way insecure they have to sort of impose certain set of rules in order to serve their interests and purposes now what is a socio-cultural metal is in which I had mentioned when we discuss which I bought from Marvin Harris socio-cultural metal is in essence in fundamental agreement with bucks when he states the ideas of the ruling class in its period are the ruling ideas the ruling ideas that is Marx when he talked about dialectical materialism and he happens to argue that it in each and every successive stage or in every society there is a ruling class and this ruling class tends to in a say innocence control by imposing their I just now in a sense while discussing this socio-cultural materialism it is also important to recall the historical metal isms of Marx now which I won’t be discussing in detail in this course and lecture so maybe if someone is interested in looking more into the dialectical if not historical materialism of Marx so you can google it and then there will be plenty of articles and metals on that now how does this elite tends to control their power dealt across societies because they have that idea as Mark said rightly pointed out the ruling class or innocence in every societies impose certain kind of ideas that is they ruled through the ideas which are made to believe to the other masses right now that’s how you tend to impose certain ideas on others and that very idea is in essence instrumental in ruling depth now if we talk about that idea of the ruling class if we take examples of the hem society prior to the friendship loosened the fence Society I mean the the citizens of France were made to believe that the king their King was the he has that guided by the idea of Divine Right theory which means he in essence is a representation of God now whatever he says he is the law now that kind of ideas in essence usually is being imposed on certain societies and if this idea is sort of being followed and abide by any members then that’s how the ruling and it tends to play with innocence their ideas now in every society if you look at there is this the dominant class that innocence tends to have a disproportionate amount of wealth and social power and in this socio-cultural metal engine it is important to make an analysis and attempt to understand or identify this class who are this class who have this disproportionate amount of social power and then why is it that they have that kind of power so which in essence has to be sort of analyzed and understood in that particular social system [Music]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top